动物源肠球菌对饲用抗菌促生长剂流行病学临界值的建立

doi:10.16431/j.cnki.1671-7236.2022.07.037

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 【目的】建立动物源肠球菌对抗菌促生长剂的流行病学临界值，并基于此了解2019-2021年动物源肠球菌对饲用抗菌促生长剂的耐药情况。【方法】测定2019-2021年从北京、河北、四川、山西、陕西和内蒙古养殖场动物样本中分离得到的肠球菌对7种抗菌促生长剂（吉他霉素、黄霉素、恩拉霉素、那西肽、阿维拉霉素、维吉尼亚霉素和杆菌肽）的最小抑菌浓度（MIC）值。根据CLSI-VET中规定的方法，利用统计软件ECOFFinder对MIC分布数据进行非线性回归模拟，以95%置信区间下的流行病学临界值计算动物源肠球菌对7种抗菌促生长剂的耐药率。【结果】确定了动物源肠球菌对吉他霉素、黄霉素、恩拉霉素、那西肽、阿维拉霉素、维吉尼亚霉素和杆菌肽的流行病学临界值分别为8、8、8、0.25、8、8和32 μg/mL。由此计算的药物耐药率为64.38%、34.48%、80.06%、14.69%、19.06%、50.69%和24.96%，其中动物源肠球菌对恩拉霉素、吉他霉素和维吉尼亚霉素的耐药情况最为严重，而对那西肽最敏感。在2019-2021年的耐药率变化情况统计中，黄霉素和杆菌肽的耐药率下降趋势较为明显。【结论】本研究制定了动物源肠球菌对7种养殖业常用抗菌促生长剂的流行病学临界值，可作为动物源肠球菌对饲用抗菌促生长剂敏感和耐药的初步判定标准，为进一步制定耐药折点，监测动物源肠球菌对抗菌促生长剂的耐药情况变化提供数据基础和科学依据。

关键词: 肠球菌; 抗菌促生长剂; 流行病学临界值; 耐药性

Abstract: 【Objective】 This study was aimed to establish the epidemiological cut-off values of Enterococcus isolated from animals for antimicrobial growth promoters and further to understand the resistance rate of animal-derived Enterococcus to antimicrobial growth promoters from 2019 to 2021.【Method】 The MICs of Enterococcus isolated from breeding farms in Beijing,Hebei,Sichuan,Shanxi,Shaanxi and Inner Mongolia from 2019 to 2021 to seven antimicrobial growth promoters (kitasamycin,flavomycin,enramycin,nasipeptide,averamycin,viginiamycin and bacitracin) were tested.According to the method specified in CLSI-VET,the non-linear regression simulation of MIC distribution data was carried out using the statistical tool ECOFFinder.The drug resistance rate of Enterococcus from animals to 7 kinds of antibacterial growth promoters was calculated by the epidemiological cut-off values under 95% confidence interval.【Result】 The epidemiological cut-off values of kitasamycin,flavomycin,enramycin,narceptide,averamycin,virinomycin and bacitracin were 8,8,8,0.25,8,8 and 32 μg/mL,respectively.Based on this,the drug resistance rates calculated were 64.38%,34.48%,80.06%,14.69%,19.06%,50.69% and 24.96%,respectively.Among them,Enterococcus was most resistant to enramycin,kitasamycin and virginiamycin,but most sensitive to nazeptide.In the statistics from 2019 to 2021,the drug resistance rates of flavomycin and bacitracin decreased relatively obviously.【Conclusion】 This study established the epidemiological cut-off values of animal-derived Enterococcus against seven antimicrobial growth promoters commonly used in aquaculture. It could be used as a preliminary criterion for determining the sensitivity and resistance of animal-derived Enterococcus to antimicrobial growth promoters and provide a scientific basis for further establishing drug resistance points and monitoring the changes of drug resistance of animal-derived Enterococcus to antimicrobial growth promoters.

Key words: Enterococcus; antimicrobial growth promoters; ECOFFs; drug resistance

中图分类号:

S852.61^＋1

杨钰莹, 王少林. 动物源肠球菌对饲用抗菌促生长剂流行病学临界值的建立[J]. 中国畜牧兽医, 2022, 49(7): 2788-2795.

YANG Yuying, WANG Shaolin. Establishment of the Epidemiological Cut-off Values of Enterococcus Isolated from Animals for Antimicrobial Growth Promoters[J]. China Animal Husbandry and Veterinary Medicine, 2022, 49(7): 2788-2795.

参考文献

[1] 农业农村部办公厅.农业农村部办公厅关于印发2021年兽药残留监控和动物源细菌耐药性监测计划的通知(农办牧
[2021] 7号)[J].中华人民共和国农业农村部公报,2021,3:46-67. GENERAL OFFICE OF THE MINISTRY OF AGRICULTURE AND RURAL AFFAIRS.Circular of the General Office of the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs on printing and distributing the 2021 plan for monitoring veterinary drug residues and antimicrobial resistance in animals[J].Gazette of the Ministry of Agriculture and Affairs of the People's Republic of China,2021,3:46-67.(in Chinese)
[2] 周芷锦,穆琳,王彬.动物源肠球菌耐药性研究进展[J].中国畜禽种业,2020,16(11):47-50. ZHOU Z J,MU L,WANG B.Advances in drug resistance of Enterococcus from animals[J].The Chinese Livestock and Poultry Breeding,2020,16(11):47-50.(in Chinese)
[3] TORRES C,ALONSO C A,RUIZ-RIPA L,et al.Antimicrobial resistance in Enterococcus spp.of animal origin[J].Microbiology Spectrum,2018,6(4).doi:10.1128/microbiolspec.ARBA-0032-2018.
[4] 于洋,方亮星,周宇峰,等.畜牧业发展中抗菌药应用的"利"与"刃"[J].中国科学院院刊,2019,34(2):152-162. YU Y,FANG L X,ZHOU Y F,et al.Benefit and risk of utilizing antimicrobials in animal husbandry development[J].Bulletin of Chinese Academy of Sciences,2019,34(2):152-162.(in Chinese)
[5] DANIEL D S,LEE S M,DYKES G A,et al.Public health risks of multiple-drug-resistant Enterococcus spp.in Southeast Asia[J].Applied and Environmental Microbiology,2015,81(18):6090-6097.
[6] 中华人民共和国农业农村部.中华人民共和国农业农村部公告第168号[J].中华人民共和国农业农村部公报,2019,5:64. MINISTRY OF AGRICULTURE AND RURAL AFFAIRS OF THE PEOPLE'S REPUBLIC OF CHINA.Announcement No.168 of the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs of the People's Rrepublic of China[J].Gazette of the Ministry of Agriculture and Affairs of the People's Republic of China,2019,5:64.(in Chinese)
[7] 李培仓.抗生素滥用对养殖业的危害及控制对策[J].中国动物检疫,2009,26(6):23-24. LI P C.Harm of antibiotics abuse to breeding industry and its control countermeasures[J].Chinese Journal of Animal Health Inspection,2009,26(6):23-24.(in Chinese)
[8] 中华人民共和国农业农村部.中华人民共和国农业农村部公告第194号[J].浙江畜牧兽医,2020,45(1):28. MINISTRY OF AGRICULTURE AND RURAL AFFAIRS OF THE PEOPLE'S REPUBLIC OF CHINA.Announcement No.194 of the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs of the People's Republic of China[J].Zhejiang Journal Animal Science and Veterinary Medicine,2020,45(1):28.(in Chinese)
[9] 陈佳莉,陈超群,吴雪,等.副猪嗜血杆菌对喹诺酮类药物流行病学临界值的建立[J].中国畜牧兽医,2021,48(11):4292-4301. CHEN J L,CHEN C Q,WU X,et al.Establishment of the epidemiological cut-off values of Haemophilus parasuis for quinolones[J].China Animal Husbandry & Veterinary Medicine,2021,48(11):4292-4301.(in Chinese)
[10] 徐紫慧,罗讯,张朋,等.动物源性细菌抗生素耐药判定标准的研究现状[J].中国抗生素杂志,2018,43(7):794-800. XU Z H,LUO X,ZHANG P,et al.Advances on the establishment of antimicrobial susceptibility breakpoints for bacteria of animal origin[J].Chinese Journal of Antibiotics,2018,43(7):794-800.(in Chinese)
[11] WATTS J L,SWEENEY M T,LUBBERS B V,et al.Antimicrobial susceptibility testing of bacteria of veterinary origin[J].Microbiology Spectrum,2018,6(2).doi:10.1128/microbiolspec.ARBA-0001-2017.
[12] TURNIDGE J,KAHLMETER G,KRONVALL G.Statistical characterisation of bacterial wild-type MIC value distributions and the determination of epidemiological cut-off values[J].Clinical Microbiology Infection,2006,12(5):418-425.
[13] 2020年中国兽用抗菌药使用情况报告[N].中国畜牧兽医报,2021-11-14(003). Report antimicrobial aonsumption in animals in China in 2020[N].China Animal Husbandry Bulletin,2021-11-14(003).(in Chinese)
[14] HAN X,DU X D,SOUTHEY L,et al.Functional analysis of a bacitracin resistance determinant located on ICECp1,a novel Tn916-like element from a conjugative plasmid in Clostridium perfringens[J].Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy,2015,59(11):6855-6865.
[15] 陈慕雅.杆菌肽耐药基因簇bcrRABD在动物源肠球菌中的流行特征研究[D].广州:华南农业大学,2018. CHEN M Y.Epidemiological characteristics of bacitracin resistance cluster bcrRABD in Enterococcus from animal[D].Guangzhou:South China Agricultural University,2018.(in Chinese)
[16] 胡玉霞,丁瑜,陈贵才.饲用抗生素--那西肽的应用研究进展[J].浙江畜牧兽医,2010,35(1):9-11. HU Y X,DING Y,CHEN G C.Research progress in the application of feeding antibiotic-naticitide[J].Zhejiang Journal Animal Science and Veterinary Medicine,2010,35(1):9-11.(in Chinese)
[17] HIDAI H.Antibiotics-TAZ/PIPC,synercid,linezolid,everninomicin[J].Nihon Rinsho,2001,59(4):785-789.
[18] 戴梦红,王玉莲,袁宗辉.抗菌促生长剂的耐药性与人类健康[J].中国兽医学报,2009,29(3):383-388. DAI M H,WANG Y L,YUAN Z H.Resistance to antimicrobial growth promoters and human health[J].Chinese Journal of Veterinary Science,2009,29(3):383-388.(in Chinese)
[19] RENDE-FOURNIER R,LECLERCQ R,GALIMAND M,et al.Identification of the satA gene encoding a streptogramin A acetyltransferase in Enterococcus faecium BM4145[J].Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy,1993,37(10):2119-2125.
[20] HAMMERUM A M,JENSEN L B,AARESTRUP F M.Detection of the satA gene and transferability of virginiamycin resistance in Enterococcus faecium from food-animals[J].FEMS Microbiology Letters,1998,168(1):145-151.
[21] WEITNAUER G,HAUSER G,HOFMANN C,et al.Novel avilamycin derivatives with improved polarity generated by targeted gene disruption[J].Chemistry & Biology,2004,11(10):1403-1411.
[22] FREI A,GOLDENBERGER D,TEUBER M.Antimicrobial susceptibility of intestinal bacteria from Swiss poultry flocks before the ban of antimicrobial growth promoters[J].Systematic and Applied Microbiology,2001,24(1):116-121.
[23] SERENSEN A H,HANSEN L H,JOHANNESEN E,et al.Conjugative plasmid conferring resistance to olaquindox[J].Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy,2003,47(2):798-799.
[24] 2018年中国兽用抗菌药使用情况报告[J].中国动物保健,2019,21(12):8-9. Report on antimicrobial consumption in animals in China in 2018[J].China Animal Health,2019,21(12):8-9.(in Chinese)
[25] 赵琪,李霆,姜子楠,等.2019年我国兽用抗菌药物使用情况分析研究[J].中国兽药杂志,2022,56(1):71-76. ZHAO Q,LI T,JIANG Z N,et al.Investigation on antimicrobial consumption in animals in China in 2019[J].Chinese Journal of Veterinary Drug,2022,56(1):71-76.(in Chinese)